NFL Salaries (part 2) - Is Average really Average?

In my last blog entry, I discussed average NFL salaries.  I had initially hoped to talk about median salaries but, with my limited internet searching skills, was not able to find enough information about the history of median NFL salaries.

When analyzing data, why do we often focus on the median instead of the average (mean)?

The fact is that the average (mean) is not always so average (typical).  If we want to get a good picture of what a typical NFL player makes, we should analyze median salaries. 

Indianapolis Colts – 2012 Salaries
Rk	Player	Salary
1	Dwight Freeney	$19,035,000
2	Antoine Bethea	$6,225,000
3	Robert Mathis	$5,750,000
4	Andrew Luck	$4,015,000
5	Reggie Wayne	$3,500,000
6	Adam Vinatieri	$3,200,000
7	Antonio Johnson	$2,000,000
8	Samson Satele	$1,866,667
9	Anthony Castonzo	$1,818,431
10	Cory Redding	$1,716,667
11	Jerry Hughes	$1,691,250
12	Winston Justice	$1,500,000
13	Austin Collie	$1,417,388
14	Donald Brown	$1,385,000
15	Pat McAfee	$1,322,500
16	Drew Stanton	$1,225,000
17	Pat Angerer	$1,132,500
18	Tom Zbikowski	$1,033,333
19	Coby Fleener	$971,000
20	Vontae Davis	$957,500
21	Fili Moala	$873,000
22	Trai Essex	$825,000
23	Mewelde Moore	$825,000
24	Jerraud Powers	$784,625
25	Darius Butler	$770,000
26	Mike McGlynn	$700,000
27	Moise Fokou	$627,438
28	Drake Nevis	$622,278
29	Donnie Avery	$615,000
30	Justin King	$615,000
31	Delone Carter	$571,301
32	Dwayne Allen	$565,826
33	Ricardo Mathews	$551,628
34	Kavell Conner	$551,309
35	Josh Gordy	$540,000
36	Jeff Linkenbach	$540,000
37	Seth Olsen	$540,000
38	Matt Overton	$540,000
39	T.Y. Hilton	$521,750
40	Sergio Brown	$490,000
41	Cassius Vaughn	$490,000
42	Joe Lefeged	$467,667
43	Kris Adams	$465,000
44	Mario Addison	$465,000
45	Martin Tevaseu	$465,000
46	Joe Reitz	$455,000
47	Vick Ballard	$426,140
48	LaVon Brazill	$409,670
49	Chandler Harnish	$401,474
50	Mario Harvey	$390,000
51	Justin Hickman	$390,000
52	Dominique Jones	$390,000
53	Nathan Palmer	$390,000
54	Bradley Sowell	$390,000
55	Jerrell Freeman	$375,000
	Source: Fox Sports*

As an example, let’s look at the salaries for the 2012 Indianapolis Colts.

This team is somewhat of an anomaly because they have the highest-paid player in the league (Dwight Freeney) and the lowest total team payroll in the league.  This makes the Colts an exaggerated microcosm of the NFL – a league in which most players earn a high salary, but a few players earn an insanely high salary.

So, how much money does the typical player on the Colts earn?

If we use average salary (rounded to the nearest dollar) the answer is $1,469,115 – but is this really typical?  43 players, representing78 percent of the team, make less than this amount.

The average salary is artificially inflated by the top-earning players on the list.  If we take the top three salaries (Freeney, Bathea, and Mathis) off of the list and recalculate the average, it becomes $957,526 (again, rounded to the nearest dollar).  Removing three players caused the average salary to decrease by about 35%.

It seems more reasonable to use median salary and state that the typical player on this team earns $622,278.  This amount is not artificially inflated by the top earners on the list.  If we remove the top three salaries, the median becomes $615,000.  This number is about 1% lower than the original median.

If the example of the Colts does not convince you that median is the better way to go, consider this example:

A group of one hundred people decide to look in their wallets to see how much money each person is carrying.  Ninety-nine of the people are carrying $1 and one person is carrying $1,000,000.  The average amount of money per person is $10,000.99 ($1,000,099 ÷ 100).  Does this mean that the typical person in this group is carrying over ten thousand dollars in his/her wallet?  Of course not.

In situations like these, median gives the best approximation of the typical case – the average is not really very average.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------

For Math Tutorials and Silly Math Songs, visit

www.onlinemathpro.com

(*Source: http://msn.foxsports.com/nfl/team/indianapolis-colts/salary/67048?q=indianapolis-colts)

Affiliate Disclosure